Four Seasons vs. Andaz vs. Nekajui: Choosing on Peninsula Papagayo (and the Option Most People Overlook)

Peninsula Papagayo has three outstanding resorts: the Four Seasons, the Andaz, and Nekajui. Here is an honest read on each, and the fourth option most visitors overlook, a private villa that gives you the resorts' best parts without the hotel room.

Author:
The Smart Villas
Miinutes
7

Peninsula Papagayo is home to three of the best resorts in Costa Rica: the Four Seasons, the Andaz, and Nekajui, a Ritz-Carlton Reserve. They are genuinely excellent, and if a hotel room is what you want, you will be well looked after at any of them.

But there is a fourth option on the peninsula that most visitors never consider, and for a lot of trips it is the better one: a private villa. This guide gives you an honest read on each resort, and then makes the case for the villa, because once you understand what the peninsula actually offers, the choice looks different than it first appears.

The Three Resorts, Honestly

Each resort has a distinct personality. Here is how we'd describe them to a guest deciding.

Four Seasons Resort Peninsula Papagayo is the established grande dame, the peninsula's first hotel and a six-time Forbes five-star property, recently refreshed in a major renovation. Its identity is warm and family-oriented: treetop rooms, two beaches, a celebrated spa, and the effortless service the brand is known for. Condé Nast once described it as "full of happy families," and that captures it. It is also the highest-priced of the three. If you want the surest, most polished, most family-friendly resort experience, this is it.

Andaz Peninsula Papagayo is the design-forward one. Built into the hillside by architect Ronald Zürcher, it leans into earth tones, natural materials, and a minimalist "jungle luxury" feel that skews a little more adult and style-conscious. Two infinity pools, strong restaurants, and a naturalist's sensibility. It sits at a noticeably lower price point than the Four Seasons, and the property is spread out across the hillside, so expect some walking or a golf-cart ride. For couples and design lovers who want character over convention, the Andaz is the pick.

Nekajui, a Ritz-Carlton Reserve is the newest and the most exclusive. It is the first Ritz-Carlton Reserve in Central or South America, a cliffside sanctuary above Pochote Bay with 107 ocean-facing rooms, suites, and treetop tents, a mosaic chapel, and Puna, arguably the best restaurant on the peninsula. Reserve is Ritz-Carlton's rarest tier, built to feel singular to its place. If ultra-luxury and a sense of occasion are the point of the trip, Nekajui is unmatched, and priced accordingly.

So that is the honest shortlist: Four Seasons for polished family luxury, Andaz for design and value, Nekajui for ultra-luxury. Any of them is a wonderful stay.

Now, the Option Most People Overlook

Here is what the resort comparison misses. On Peninsula Papagayo, you do not have to choose between a resort and everything else, because a private villa gives you the resorts' best parts and the things a hotel room cannot.

A villa gives you the whole house, not a room

A resort gives you a room, or a suite if you pay for it, and a pool you share with every other guest. A villa gives you an entire home: multiple bedrooms, your own private pool, a full kitchen, living and dining space, and terraces that are yours alone. For a family, a group of friends, or a multigenerational trip, that difference is the whole trip. Nobody is cramped into connecting rooms. Everyone has space. The pool is never crowded because it is yours.

For a group, it costs less, not more

This surprises people. The Four Seasons starts well north of $900 a night for one room, and Nekajui higher still. Put a family or a group in a resort and you are booking several rooms at that rate. A villa that sleeps your whole group is one booking, and per person it often comes in well below the cost of the equivalent resort rooms, while giving everyone far more space. The math usually favors the villa the moment you are more than two people.

You still get the resorts, without staying in them

This is the part that changes the decision. As a registered villa guest on the peninsula, the resorts' best features are open to you anyway. You can book dinner at Puna at Nekajui, spend a day at a beach club, play the Arnold Palmer golf course, and use Papagayo Park, all while going home to your own house rather than a hotel corridor. You are not giving up the resorts by staying in a villa. You are adding a private home to them. You get the Four Seasons' restaurants, the Andaz's beach club, Nekajui's dining, without being locked into any single property's room, rate, or rhythm.

Your own concierge, not a front desk

A good villa comes with a dedicated concierge who arranges the boat days, the private chef, the beach club passes, the restaurant reservations, the airport transfer, and the golf tee times. It is similar to the resort's concierge service, except it works only for you and your group, and it starts before you arrive. For many of our guests, the private-chef dinner on their own terrace ends up being the meal they remember from the whole trip, and no resort restaurant quite matches it.

Real privacy

A resort, however luxurious, is a public space. A villa is not. For a honeymoon, a family gathering, a group celebrating something, or simply a trip where you want to be off-duty and unobserved, the privacy of a whole house to yourselves is something the resorts structurally cannot offer.

So Which Should You Choose?

If you are two people who want to be fully looked after in a hotel and never think about a single detail, a resort room is a lovely way to travel, and you cannot go wrong with any of the three above.

But if you are a family, a group, or anyone who values space, privacy, a kitchen, a pool of your own, and a concierge devoted to just your party, while still having the peninsula's resorts, restaurants, beach clubs, golf, and park open to you, a private villa is the better option on Peninsula Papagayo. You give up nothing and gain a great deal at a better price.

That is the case we make, and it is why our guests tend to come back to the villa rather than the resort.

Some places deserve more than a hotel, even a very good one. If you are weighing where to stay on Peninsula Papagayo, reach out through thesmartvillas.com and we will match you to the right villa and build the trip around it, resorts included.

Peninsula Papagayo Resorts: Frequently Asked Questions

What are the resorts on Peninsula Papagayo? There are three: the Four Seasons Resort Peninsula Papagayo (established, family-oriented, five-star), the Andaz Peninsula Papagayo (design-forward, a bit more adult, better value), and Nekajui, a Ritz-Carlton Reserve (the newest and most exclusive). There is also the Club at Peninsula Papagayo, which is an owners-only membership rather than a resort a visitor can book.

‍Which Peninsula Papagayo resort is best for families? The Four Seasons is the most family-oriented of the three, with a warm, polished, family-friendly identity. That said, for a family a private villa is often the better choice overall, more space, a private pool, a kitchen, and a lower per-person cost than booking multiple resort rooms, while still giving the family access to the resorts' restaurants, beach clubs, golf, and Papagayo Park.

Is it cheaper to stay in a villa or a resort on Peninsula Papagayo? For a couple, a resort room and a villa can be comparable. For a family or a group, a villa is the better value: one booking for the whole party, far more space, and a per-person cost that typically comes in below the equivalent set of resort rooms.

Can villa guests use the resort restaurants and beach clubs? Yes. As a registered Peninsula Papagayo villa guest you can book the resorts' restaurants, access beach clubs (day-pass fees apply), play the Arnold Palmer golf course, and use Papagayo Park, so a villa adds a private home without giving up the resorts' amenities.

Which resort has the best dining? Nekajui is the standout, with Chef Diego Muñoz's Peruvian restaurant Puna widely considered the best on the peninsula, though the Four Seasons and Andaz both have excellent restaurants. All are open to villa guests, which is a strong argument for staying in a villa and dining across all three.

‍

Luxury villa pool deck at golden hour
BEGIN YOUR STAY

Let us craft something extraordinary.

Arrange a consultation with our team. We'll understand what you need, then tailor a residence and itinerary to fit — usually within a few hours.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Frequently asked questions.

Everything you need for a seamless stay

What makes The Smart Villas different from Airbnb or VRBO?

The Smart Villas is a curated collection of luxury villas, not a marketplace. That means no platform fees, no service charges, and no algorithm deciding what you see. Booking directly with us typically saves guests 12–15% compared to the same property listed on Airbnb or VRBO.

Every home is individually selected, and every stay is concierged by our team from arrival to departure. Guests don't deal with an app or a call center. They deal with people who know these homes personally and handle every detail — transfers, restaurant reservations, local experiences — as a baseline, not an add-on.

Is a private villa or the Four Seasons better in Papagayo?

Staying in a Smart Villa means you get the full Papagayo resort experience without being confined to one property.

‍Golf cart to the Four Seasons for dinner. Walk to the Ritz-Carlton Reserve for a spa treatment. Hit the Arnold Palmer Golf Course in the morning, come home to your private pool in the afternoon. The beach clubs, the restaurants, the activities, all of it is accessible.

You're just not paying resort prices to sleep in a hotel room when you could have an entire home. The guests who choose a villa aren't skipping the resort experience. They're adding to it.

How quickly do you answer?

We usually answer in a matter of minutes to all new messages.

Still have questions?

We're happy to assist you with any questions regarding your stay, destination, or tailored travel experience.

Contact us